Book ron is actually a good friend and a valuable member of the team. What ron would say if he was a selfaware character. They miss an entire game of quidditch against hufflepuff. He bullies students to the verge of tears, is blatantly biased towards slytherins, and does not care for an innocent life just because of a childhood grudge. Some she only revealed after the last book had been written, some are found by fans, and some arent hidden at all. Snape would get destroyed, keep in mind the reason.
Severus snape and lilly evansjames potter i think harry perfers lupin and hagrids memoirs, haha. The sorcerers stone movie is probably the closest overall to the book, as the book is the shortest. Movie although the first movie in the harry potter franchise is very accurate, the book still has much more detail about everything. Ive just started the fourth book, so no major spoilers please. In the movie harry kept the secret of hunting horcruxes to himself, ron and hermione as per dumbledores explicit instructions. So, when the prisoner of azkaban movie was released 10 years ago on june 4. List of differences between the harry potter books and. Did the setting in the movie look like you had imagined it. Differences between harry potter and the half blood prince.
Harry potter and the half blood prince that was not in the book. Apr 28, 2011 for those who have read the books and seen the movies. Sep 30, 2019 the second half of dh part 2 was a total disappointment. There are spoilers of major scenes, events and deaths. Movie with all the new movies based on books or comics that are out, people wonder why hollywood keeps doing it. Differences between harry potter and the deathly hallows. This movie was based off the bestselling novel, which was written in 1997 by j. The movies are condensed and we dont see quite as much of snape as we do in the books. The second half of dh part 2 was a total disappointment.
Also, the weasleys have a lot more to do with the book than in the movie. A definitive reading is a must read for general fans as well as those of us who have a snapecentric love of the harry potter series. Harry potter and the sorcerers stone movie was very accurate to the book, but just didnt have important details like how harry potters eyes are green, the sorting hat didnt sort right and sing a song, and how at the end of the book, there was no potions task in general. What were some disappointing differences between harry. The crucial differences between snape in the books and films. Harry potter fanatics know that there is a world of difference between the magical books and their respective film adaptations. For example, despite the fact that the movies are iconic to so many people, some characters dont exactly match their descriptions from the books. These differences are more pronounced as the books grow larger and the story more complex, but lets start with the first one. Seeing hagrid give this enlightening news to harry brings delight to the common viewer, who has seen harry bullied by. Professor snape who switched his loyalty to dumbledore years ago and igor karkaroff, the headmaster for durmstrang institute, who years. Jul 12, 2014 let me preface this by saying that harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban is my favorite book of the entire series.
Its 2018over 10 years since the book release of harry potter and the deathly hallowsand there is hardly a shortage of diehard harry potter fans. Movie snape and book snape, despite having similar stories, are very different people. When i was 11, i read harry potter and the sorcerers stone for the first time. The way albus dumbledore is described in the books versus how hes. Tons about lily and james potter points in time by julvett on deviantart poor snape the life of severus snape. While the potter movies are nostalgic and possess a special charm of. Director mike newell the first british director in the series. List of differences between the harry potter books and films. In the movie, however, that is all that the map says. Oct 16, 20 even with small changes to the story, this one is perhaps the movie with the least differences from the book. What are the differences between movie snapes and book snape. Rereading the series to my wife, who cant read novels after she had a brain tumor removed, damaging her working.
With the release of harry potter and the cursed child followed by the movie and screenplay release of fantastic beasts and where to find them the harry potter community is back again. And in harry potter and the halfblood prince, at first glance, youll find its rather similar in both the book and the film. When comparing a book and a film, or something similar, the first thing one thinks about is obviously the plot. He captures snape so well, i now picture movie snape when i read the books. In the movie the dursleys are still part of harrys life. Why was the ending of the book different from the ending of the movie in regards to the elder wand. In the movie, it is hermione who comes across the name in a book she picked up for light reading. How is the book version of severus snape different than. Sprout and flitwick duel snape in the great hall after harry returns and informs them that snape killed dumbledore. Harry potter and the philosophers stone was the first moviebook in the franchise. List of differences between the harry potter books and films harry. This also omits the scene where harry tries to get the book back and snape is bandaging his wounded leg. Book severus vs movie severus books vs movies, harry.
Mar 21, 2014 harry potter and the order of phoenix has a lot a lot a lot of differences between the movie and the book as the books grew larger and the movies were still under 3 hours, a lot of compromises were done and a lot of stories were shaved off harry potter and the philosophers stone. I agree that the difference between the movie snape and book snape is a lot. When so many people including snape before biting the dust point out the. Deathly hallows is my second favorite book in the series, and it is currently my favorite movie of the series. I think alan rickman was a joy to watch as snapesmooth, and cold, and deadly in his calculations. Harry meets dumbledore at a restaurant in the train station. Movie snape mouthed the words, but book snape, to my mind had an utterly original voice that was simultaneously trapped in an anguished adolescence, still fighting battles there, and striving to avoid adult interactions. For those who have read the books and seen the movies.
How is the book version of severus snape different than the. Harry potter moviebook comparison sorcerers stone quiz. Rowling, called harry potter and the sorcerers stone. The film was loved by fans, but deviated from the source material. If you were to read this book and watch the movie you would find many differences, but the main difference between the two is that the book gives more information to the reader than the movie gives to the. In harry potter and the sorcerers stone, harry, an orphan, lives with the dursleys, his horrible aunt and. Severus snape and lily evans he did not love lily potter, because then her heart belonged to james snape and lily evans he did not love lily potter, because at that point he became obsessive and being obsessed with someone isnt love, but its still cute. Even in the duelling club, while duelling against lockthart, in the. In the book, when professor snape is insulted by the marauders map, each marauder says something different to professor snape, with lupin saying the bit about snape minding his own business. Even though alan rickman, who plays snape, is no underwear model, i must dare to say that the movie didnt do a well enough. I didnt enjoy the movies because the acting was bad for the most part with the exception of the few i named before, and because of the character developement throughout the movies wasnt great. Let me preface this by saying that harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban is my favorite book of the entire series. Professor snape, harrys potion teacher, is suppose to be really ugly in the book.
What were some disappointing differences between harry potter. Harry potter and the order of phoenix has a lot a lot a lot of differences between the movie and the book as the books grew larger and the movies were still under 3 hours, a lot of compromises were done and a lot of stories were shaved off. Rowling brought us the world of harry potter and endowed it with an impressive number of secrets. Professor snape was very distant through out the entire film. Harry potter half blood prince book compared to movie. Harry tells aberforth about the mission that dumbledore had assigned to him. Even with small changes to the story, this one is perhaps the movie with the least differences from the book. Book vs movie july 11, 20 blinksan so, my mom, sister and i started this thing for lack of a better term where we read the harry potter books one by one and watch the movies with each corresponding book. However, movies takes at most 4 hours of your time, such as the movie lord of the rings 3, but the average length of a movie is between 1. In the novel, hermione slaps malfoy and he reacts passively. His rage was removed, his movements careful and studied. Harry replaces the elder wand in dumbledores tomb vs movie. Where was brave neville, proclaiming his loyalty to dumbledore and condescendingly telling voldy that he would join hi.
This post is a comparison of major plot points in the movie and book versions of harry potter and the deathly hallows pt. Ang lees sense and sensibility brings jane austens words to stunning life. Drawn out scenes or interactions in the books are much shorter in the movies and we get less detail in some ways. Draco uses the vanishing cabinet in the room of requirement to penetrate the hogwarts defenses. Harry potter and the sorcerers stone movie was very accurate to the book, but just didnt have important details like how harry potters eyes are green, the sorting hat didnt sort right and sing a song. I found myself, at times, forgetting that this was the halfblood prince movie.
The first thing i noticed, imo, of course, is the snape in the book is meaner than the one in the movie. What if the characters of harry potter looked like they did in the books. Alas, when the potter movies got the movie treatment, adhering to the. What are the differences between movie snapes and book snapes personality. Author lorrie kim uses multiple sources beyond the rowling books and includes quotes extensively from the series for an intensive analysis of, to my mind, rowlings most interesting characterseverus. When so many people including snape before biting the dust point out the fact that harry has his mothers eyes, despite the fact that the actors in the movies had eyes that couldnt be more different if they tried, the translation from book to screen is marred from the getgo. Top 10 shocking differences between the harry potter. Good ones for this are the harry potter series, holes, the chronicles of. No booktofilm adaptation is perfect, but for a long time, harry potter fans have felt that the philosophers stone was the closest to perfect that fandom got. Voldemort easy, even dumbledore was a challenge for voldemort and he had the elder wand. But the order of the phoenix film was so shallow in comparison with the corresponding book anyway. Harry potter severus snape x lily evans snily her artwork on harry potter characters is amazing.
Some say theyre greedy people, just doing it for the money, and others say that it. The severus snape from the harry potter films is different from the one in. Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 this is long, just so you know. Harry, ron and hermione, the main trio, go to hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry for their sixth year. A lot of people would rather watch a movie than read a book, claiming that it is not worth spending effort and time as you can watch the movie without requiring much effort from your side. In the book, there is a battle fought between the order of the phoenix, dumbledores army and the death eaters. In the book, professor snape treats harry to a tirade about how harrys father was a troublemaker at school, but this scene is not featured in the movie. Watching a movie after reading the book is a wonderful way to encourage students to think critically about how each medium presented roughly the same information. At least, thats the glass halffull way to look at it. Top 10 shocking differences between the harry potter movies.
Its 2018over 10 years since the book release of harry potter and the deathly. What ron would say if he was a selfaware character i draw comics and yell. Book severus vs movie severus books vs movies, harry potter. Rowling and how the book compared to the movie summary overview.
Good ones for this are the harry potter series, holes, the chronicles of narnia series, and where. The movie that i waited years to watch became a torture to sit through. Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 book vs movie add a difference. Im not the biggest fan of him so i of course prefer the book version, but i also think it makes for a much more nuanced character. Snape is one of the most loved and most interesting characters in the harry. Some say theyre greedy people, just doing it for the money, and others say that it helps bring the book to life. I was the same age as harry when he first received his hogwarts letter. Harry potter quiz full provided harry potter spells book all harry potter characters kawaii another harry potter best.
Dumbledore goes to privet drive to pick him up before the start of school. While i didnt expect to be first in line for the final harry potter movie, at 11 p. Harry potter and the deathly hallows that was not in the book. The book snape was a complete jerk with no care for whats right and wrong. In the book, professor snape treats harry to a tirade about how harrys father was a troublemaker at school, but. Narcissa malfoy asks snape to swear the unbreakable vow. Voldemortno horcruxes vs severus snape battles comic. However, as with every booktomovie adaptation, there are slight differences that may not be apparent upon ones first reading or watching. House elves are mistreated, but play vital roles vs movie. He never inhabited the castle the way he inhabited tawdry spinners way. Who first says the word, quidditch in front of harry. There is a reason for that, which was so poorly recognized in the movie. Movie starting with harry potter and the sorcerers stone, we start out with harry potter growing up and learning he is actually a wizard.
22 158 1352 1282 316 400 1102 788 206 809 1347 1623 466 1510 390 863 1481 961 586 221 1404 1256 1464 1570 1418 104 511 1227 189 54 52 405 802 1048 17 4 1414 183 1025